Search

Yeah, because I don't give a crap. What I do give a crap about is someone trying to silence dissent. But there *you* go. You ignored my point and opt to just circlejerk *your* own agenda. ...

There you go. You ignored the link I posted and opt to just circle jerk your own agenda. No one is talking about the ROOT cause. You don't understand the video LOL You don't understand what i'm s...

*My* argument is that it isn't a jerk-like thing to call scientific validity into question. And it isn't. You can circle his wagon until the cows come home, and that's just whatever. I take issue with...

I don't get this post. The video is not talking about the root cause. The video is her conceptualizing speech blocks. She says that quite clearly in the first 30 seconds of her video. There is sc...

> there is no root cause Did you not read my comment? I said that we haven't discovered a root cause yet. But what we do know is what the root cause *isn't*, and it isn't emotional in nature. I'...

No it hasn't. Have you actually read any of the scientific research? They have found correlations, but there is no root cause. Psychosocial and emotional components of stuttering has shown eviden...

The irony. You're the one misguiding the community here. There's research on this: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0094730X12000617 Read her comments she mentions ACT....

There's scientific research on what she's saying. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0094730X12000617 Don't get lost in the semantics of this all by claiming she making causation clai...

Oh look there is scientific research that backs up her claims. She uses forms of CBT to manage who stutter. Seems like you just don't understand what she's saying. Read the comments on her video i...

Do you want to chat on Skype then about it? Curious to see how you sound like and what you do about your stutter to get on your high horse and deter people from listening to other stutterers with new...

And how far has science with it's data and reports helped you with your stutter? I'm sure that's helped you enough to stop lurking around here....

Scientists are going in the wrong direction at their snail-like pace with stuttering. I think i'm open to hearing new things. The dialogue must stay open. I consider a stutter, with an academic ba...

again if you can refute it please do, but since psychogenic stuttering is pretty rare it cant just be dismissed because you believe otherwise. I'd suggest you to look it up. I'm not mixing the two up...

To be honest scientists have been contradicting eachother over and over again and to be totally honest i think i stutter because of an earlier trauma in childhood so again i kind of connect with her v...

That's just a tone argument, yeah? It's not unfair to say that scientists should be the ones making such bold statements about causal links. They could have been sweeter, but I don't think the OP was ...

It is not about whether she is right or wrong, ''Let's let the scientists spend time on this instead, okay? Please.'' sounds very derogatory to me atleast and is not needed. And on topic I think ever...

I don't think that's fair at all. The person in the video is making causation claims (that aren't being presented as mere theories) that simply aren't founded and haven't been proven. This is how misi...

I'm not really seeing where I'm acting like a jerk?... At any rate, I absolutely agree that it's good if someone is managing their stutter. That doesn't mean they get a free pass from critical commen...

This isn't scientifically valid. Neither the language/consciousness theory underlying it, nor the stutter theory presented. Let's let the scientists spend time on this instead, okay? Please....

If you live near a university with cs&d they give you reduced rate. I try not to feel bitter, but it's hard. Having a grudge against stuttering is like hating yourself and you shouldnt have yo...