While I totally understand and feel your pain, why didn't you actually tell them you had a stutter? I've learned that whenever I end up stuttering in front of people I newly meet, I'm quick to let them know about it, even if I'm stumbling over my words. In my experience this almost always leads to them realizing how rude they just were and start apologizing. If the girl even said she "thought you had a problem" that even shows the situation may have been totally different if you had just let them know. Even if the situation would have been the same if you had told them, it's seriously not worth fussing over. People like that are so shallow it's insane. I know it's hard to just brush off, but trust me, there's gonna be more chances at scenarios like these.   I don't mean to be "that guy", and I've had my fair share of crappy situations like this, but I've learned how to make future situations better. It sucks, but you gotta live and learn from things like this. By the way, bro, you walked up to two attractive chicks and engaged in conversation no problem. Don't let a hiccup mid-way through mess you up; that took balls, no matter how minimal your stutter usually is. *EDIT: /u/BadJimFred made a fine point. You'd be surprised how many girls find stuttering or any kind of impediment attractive.